VA Code Red: Virginia’s Substantial Risk Order, Hearings, and Penalties

Virginia’s red flag law lets a law enforcement officer or a Commonwealth’s Attorney ask a court to temporarily bar someone from buying, having, or carrying firearms when that person poses a substantial risk of injuring themselves or others. The process is built around two orders: a short emergency order that can be issued the same day without the subject present, and a longer substantial risk order that follows a full hearing. The authority sits in Virginia Code §§ 19.2-152.13 and 19.2-152.14.

Who Can Ask a Court for the Order

Only two people can file the petition: a law enforcement officer or an attorney for the Commonwealth.1Virginia Code Commission. Virginia Code 19.2-152.13 – Emergency Substantial Risk Order Family members, roommates, therapists, co-workers, and private citizens cannot petition directly. What they can do is report their concern to police and ask for an investigation.

Before any petition is filed, law enforcement must conduct an independent investigation confirming that grounds exist. The petition goes to the court under oath and is backed by a sworn affidavit. The judge or magistrate can consider recent threats, acts of violence, or self-harm, along with police reports and witness statements.

How the Emergency Order Works

The first petition is heard ex parte. The person it targets is not present and gets no advance notice, which is what lets a court act quickly when the danger looks immediate. The standard at this stage is probable cause, the same threshold used for an arrest warrant.1Virginia Code Commission. Virginia Code 19.2-152.13 – Emergency Substantial Risk Order

If the judge or magistrate finds probable cause that the person poses a substantial risk of injury through firearm possession, the emergency order issues on the spot. It bars the subject from purchasing, possessing, or transporting any firearm while the order is in effect.

The order takes effect the moment law enforcement personally serves it. Along with the order, the subject gets a copy of the petition, the supporting affidavit, and a notice explaining the right to a hearing and to be represented by a lawyer. The emergency order expires at 11:59 p.m. on the fourteenth day after issuance. If the circuit court is not in session that day, it extends to the next business day the court sits.2Virginia Code Commission. Virginia Code 19.2-152.13 – Emergency Substantial Risk Order

The Full Hearing in Circuit Court

Within fourteen days of the emergency order, the circuit court holds a hearing on whether a longer substantial risk order should issue.3Virginia Code Commission. Virginia Code 19.2-152.14 – Substantial Risk Order This one is adversarial. You can attend, hire a lawyer, present evidence, and call witnesses. The Commonwealth’s Attorney argues for the order and carries the burden of proof.

The standard goes up at this stage. The Commonwealth must prove by clear and convincing evidence that the person poses a substantial risk of injury through firearm possession. If the court finds the evidence falls short, it dismisses the case and orders any surrendered firearms returned.

If the court is persuaded, it issues a substantial risk order for a period the judge sets, up to a maximum of 180 days. The court can continue the hearing for good cause when the subject asks, and the emergency order stays in effect until the continued hearing.

What Happens After 180 Days

The order does not simply disappear and prevent the state from acting again. Before the 180-day period ends, a prosecutor or officer can file a written motion asking the court to extend it. The judge holds a fresh hearing and applies the same clear-and-convincing-evidence standard. If the risk is still established, the court can renew the order for up to another 180 days, and there is no cap on how many times that can happen.

Surrendering Firearms

Both the emergency and the final order advise the subject to voluntarily relinquish any firearms to the law enforcement agency that served the order. The statute uses the word “voluntarily” and sets no specific deadline. The practical window is immediate, though, because possessing a firearm at any point while the order is active is a crime.

When the agency takes custody, it must give you a written receipt listing each firearm. Keep that receipt. You will need it later to get your guns back.

If an officer has reason to believe you did not turn over everything, the officer can apply for a search warrant.3Virginia Code Commission. Virginia Code 19.2-152.14 – Substantial Risk Order

Transferring Firearms to Someone Else

Instead of leaving guns in a police evidence room for months, you can ask the court to approve a transfer to another person. The conditions are strict. The transferee must be at least 21, cannot live in your household, and cannot be prohibited from possessing firearms. Both you and the proposed transferee must appear at the hearing, the Commonwealth’s Attorney has to confirm the transferee passes a background check, and the court must approve the arrangement. Once approved, the agency delivers the firearms to the transferee within five days.

Penalties for Possessing a Firearm While the Order Is in Effect

Buying, possessing, or transporting any firearm while subject to either the emergency or the final order is a Class 1 misdemeanor.4Virginia Code Commission. Virginia Code 18.2-308.1:6 – Purchase, Possession, or Transportation of Firearms by Person Subject to Substantial Risk Order That is the most serious misdemeanor classification in Virginia and carries up to 12 months in jail, a fine of up to $2,500, or both.

If you hold a concealed handgun permit, the same statute requires you to surrender it to the court that entered the order. Carrying concealed while the order is active is separately prohibited, regardless of your prior permit.

Ending the Order Early

The rules depend on which order is in place. While the emergency order is active, the subject can file a motion to dissolve at any time with the circuit court, and there is no limit on how many times you can try.2Virginia Code Commission. Virginia Code 19.2-152.13 – Emergency Substantial Risk Order

Once a final substantial risk order is in place, you get one dissolution motion during the life of the order, and you cannot file it until at least 30 days after the order was entered. At the hearing, the court looks at whether the risk that justified the order still exists. If circumstances have meaningfully changed, the court can lift the order early.

Getting Your Firearms Back

When the order expires or is dissolved, return is not automatic. You submit a written request to the law enforcement agency holding the firearms, along with a copy of the receipt you were given at surrender. The agency then has five days to return them, but only after confirming you are no longer under any active order and are not otherwise prohibited from possessing firearms.5Virginia Code Commission. Virginia Code 19.2-152.15 – Return or Disposal of Firearms

If you lost the receipt, expect delays. The statute specifically requires a copy of it with the written request. Contact the agency that originally took custody and start there.

Orders From Other States

Virginia’s penalty statute reaches beyond Virginia-issued orders. Possessing firearms in Virginia while subject to a substantially similar order from another state, a U.S. territory, or the District of Columbia is also a Class 1 misdemeanor.4Virginia Code Commission. Virginia Code 18.2-308.1:6 – Purchase, Possession, or Transportation of Firearms by Person Subject to Substantial Risk Order Whether another state will honor a Virginia order going the other direction depends on that state’s own laws. No federal statute requires interstate recognition, and enforcement across state lines is inconsistent.